Jun 24 2010

No confusion on merits of socialism versus capitalism

Category: Agriculture | General | Texas AgricultureGene Hall @ 20:09

By Gene Hall
Not long ago the respected polling group Rasmuessen released a survey with some disturbing numbers. It caused some to conclude that many Generation X and Y Americans are confused about the relative merits of socialism as opposed to capitalism. I hope confusion is to blame here, because the numbers are pretty scary.

According to Rasmuessen, only 37 percent of Americans under age 30 endorse capitalism over socialism. Socialism’s fans clocked in at 33 percent. That leaves 30 percent with no opinion on one of history’s most conclusive lessons.

I can think of no reason why these numbers should be that close. History’s verdict is indisputable. Socialism is an empty and failed economic system. From the Soviet collective farms of the past to the current economic crisis in Greece, socialism has been a resounding and complete failure. When Americans, young or old are asked which is better, the answer has to be a ringing endorsement of capitalism. Our system has created more wealth for ordinary folks than any other in history. Capitalism has fed more people and spurred more progress. Incentives work. Since socialism has no individual incentives, the seed of its failure were sown at its inception. That some want to try it here is a disturbing concept.

Let’s be clear. The United States is not a socialist nation, despite recent claims to the contrary. Neither is it purely capitalistic. I believe the trends are running more toward the socialist side of the ledger, but our economy remains mostly driven by capitalism. I suppose we’ve become kind of a hybrid economy, still bending toward free markets, while flirting with socialism.

There’s good reason for this hybridization. As recent events illustrate, capitalism can go off the rails if there aren’t a few grownups in the room. This is a lesson Theodore Roosevelt taught the nation a century ago, and we are relearning it now. Prudent regulation seems necessary, but free markets are vital to sustained economic growth.

Agriculture is very dependent on free markets. In the Soviet collective farms, much work was deferred or never completed because there was no direct link between labor and reward. In many socialist nations, during the last quarter century, experiments in allowing people to plant their own crops and even sell some of the harvest have been very successful. China has implemented capitalism without democracy. Even a devoted socialist like Raul Castro has decreed that Cubans may now plant their own crops in broke and desperate socialist Cuba.

Yet, the enthusiasm some display for the concepts of socialism is more than disturbing. It’s frightening. An angry and restless America is searching for answers. As history shows, socialism is not one of them.

 

Visit the Texas Farm Bureau website at www.txfb.org.
Follow us on Twitter and Facebook for the latest updates on this topic and many more.

 

Share on Facebook

Comments

1.
topsy.com says:

Pingback from topsy.com

Twitter Trackbacks for
        
        www.texasfarmbureau.org/.../...sus-capitalism.aspx
        [txfb.org]
        on Topsy.com

2.
Marcia United States says:

Another great article Gene--and very timely as we approach the celebration of our nation's freedom.  Maybe if that poll had identified capitalism with freedom, the numbers would have been less scary.

And regarding your comment "I can think of no reason why these numbers should be that close. History’s verdict is indisputable."  Maybe that's your reason.  It brings to mind the saying attributed to the writings of George Santanya, the Spanish-born American author of the late 19th and early 20th centuries: "Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it."  (Yes, I admit Google is a Godsend these days!).  But it's true; studying history is necessary to avoid repeating past mistakes.

Again, good job, Gene.

3.
Custom Blog Design United States says:

Capitalism is certainly better than the socialism ala USSR. It's a great motivator of human enterprise. The number you mentioned just reflect the general feeling about the economic crisis caused not by capitalism but greed and lack of proper regulation.

4.
Marcia United States says:

Custom Blog Design,

You are probably right about the current economic situation factoring into the data.  But the point is that 33 percent think socialism is the way to fix it.  If you’re dropped off shackled at prison, it doesn’t matter if you got there by bus or by car; you’re still there.

5.
juliemurphree.org says:

Pingback from juliemurphree.org

Julie’s Fresh Air » Continuing Good Content from Another Aggie Blogger

Add comment




  Country flag

biuquote
  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading