Aug 23 2010

Using cruelty to animals as a shield, activists define Texas meat lovers as rednecks

Category: Agriculture | GeneralMike Barnett @ 22:59

Texas Farm Bureau: Using cruelty to animals as a shield, animal activists use cruelty to animals to define Texas meat lovers as rednecks

By Mike Barnett

You might be a redneck if your dinner ever mooed, oinked or clucked. That’s a new twist as animal activists continue to use cruelty in animals in Texas and other states as a reason for you to quit eating meat.

I never heard Jeff Foxworthy use that line. But it’s a sentiment expressed by Bryan Monell, an activist who has frequently obtained illicit employment at farms and research facilities in order to obtain undercover video footage. He mocked the work of both farmers and researchers, as reported by the Animal Agriculture Alliance, a non-profit group who communicates the important role livestock agriculture plays in our nation’s economy.

"These people are rednecks and we are superior," he reportedly said at the recent Animal Rights 2010 conference. I’ll take it for granted that he means meat eaters as well.

So just call me Bubba and give me a bucket of KFC. If eating meat makes a redneck, certify me. I guess I’ll be a card-carrying member of Rednecks ‘R’ Us. And I’ll be joined by the 97 percent of all Americans who love meat.

Monell’s statement speaks volumes of the attitude prevalent in the animal rights activist movement. If you eat meat or raise livestock, you are inferior to Monell and friends. They perceive meat lovers to be one or several steps down the social, economic and intellectual ladders in their elitist worlds.

It would be easy to say these animal rights activists are on the far edge of sanity and dismiss their thoughts as rants from the vegan crowd. That’s what agriculture has always done. To a large extent we continue to do so. And it’s put livestock agriculture in a tenuous situation. Referendums which restrict livestock production practices and are backed by the animal rights crowd have been passed in California and several other states.

These animal rights activists are gaining traction. Cruelty to animals in Texas and other states is a mask for their true intentions. They want everyone to quit eating meat. They are serious. And agriculture must take them seriously.

Here’s a list of some of the other quotes that came out of the Animal Rights 2010 Conference and the Humane Society of the United States-hosted Taking Action for Animals, two of the nation's largest animal rights events, both held in July. The list was compiled by the Animal Agriculture Alliance.

• “Owning animals is the equivalent of slavery.”—Hope Bohenic, In Defense of Animals, AR 2010
• “I have no problem with breaking and entering, destroying labs, burning buildings and busting open cages.”—Camille Hankins, Win Animals Rights and spokesperson for Animal Liberation Front, AR 2010
•  “The dog they walked last night is no different than the pig they ate for breakfast.”—Jerry Cesak, Radio Personality and Proponent of HSUS ‘Yes on Prop 2’ Campaign, TAFA
• "Any state with an initiative process is on our radar." –Jennifer Hillman, Humane Society of the United States, TAFA

Folks, let me repeat: it’s not about animal welfare. True intentions were best expressed by Gene Bauer of Farm Sanctuary, who made the following statement at the TAFA meeting: “I dream of a vegan world—that’s where I want everything to go."

Mr. Monell and all of your friends: My neck may be red according to your definition. But so is my meat. If you want to be a vegan, that’s fine with me. But don’t try to force your values upon me and my fellow Americans.

So praise the Lord and pass the pork chops. If eating meat defines who I am, then I’m proud to be a redneck!

Visit the Texas Farm Bureau website at www.txfb.org.
Follow us on Twitter and Facebook for the latest updates on this topic and many more.

Share on Facebook

Comments

1.
Dan Dierschke United States says:

A very interesting article last week reported that fossilzed bones have been found with stone tool cut marks indicating that our ancestors were meat eaters 3.4 million years ago. The time was determined by layers of volcanic ash. This destroys the contention of vegans who insist our ancestors had a entirely plant based diet. The authors pointed out the shift from plants corresponded to the development of larger brained individuals since the more nutrient dense meat gave the necessary ingredients for brain development.

Mike, from one redneck to another, enjoy that nature provided meat and may our redneck species thrive.

2.
Carl Marugg United States says:

Good blog Mike. Let them have it.

3.
melissa United States says:

This blog post is appalling. Just as you do not want some vegan hippie castrating you based on your diet, it is a tad hypocritical to flaunt a cheek full of ribeye as your retort. You are no better than Mr. Monell or the people you criticize when you stereotype people by their diet. Shame on you for publishing this in a state agency blog.

4.
ghall United States says:

Ah, another anonymous post. Such courage. The Texas Farm Bureau is not a state agency.  It is an organization of farmers and ranchers.  We eat meat.  We raise meat.  We defend the right of all Americans to eat meat, wear leather clothes and to hunt and fish. And we intend to expose the animal rights movement for what it is - a long range plan to outlaw the consumption of animal products.  Thanks for posting - most of us use our full names here. - Gene Hall

5.
Cynthia United States says:

GREAT ARTICLE and now PEtA is "out of the closet" for wanting to be sure Lubbuck does Mandatory Neuter/Spay with an alert to their people saying to make it a "no birth nation" with animals!!

6.
melissa United States says:

Rather than attack my choice to withhold my last name, why don't you stick to the issue. To allege that "the consumption of animal products" would ever be outlawed is an outrageous conspiracy theory. And while you defend the right to free choice and bacon, I would also like to defend mine. Why should vegetarians/vegans be attacked for exercising freedom of choice?

7.
ghall United States says:

Melisa - I am not attacking you at all. I really have no problem with folks not using a last name.  I'm just pointing out that I do not have that luxury.  I will say no more about it. Mike and I must stand behind everything we write. If you read a few of the posts on this blog, you'll understand that we are all about EVERYONE having the freedom of food choices. I have no problem with anyone choosing a vegan or vegetarian diet. You would not have to Google very much to conclude that it's the proponents of veganism who are trying to push their lifestyle choice on the rest of us.  You have not read of Mike and I advocating any such thing. Mike was very clear.  He was responding to documented statements from the vegan movement.  They are equally clear.  They intend to eliminate meat from the American diet. You know this and your're engaging in a rather weak attempt to twist the issue into something we did not say.  But thanks for trying!

8.
mbarnett United States says:

Melissa, groups like HSUS continue to make inroads in restricting the way producers raise their livestock. Do California, Colorado, Florida and Ohio come to mind? I'm not attacking vegans. I think I've made it clear that I'm fine if that's the lifestyle they choose to live. I wish they'd respect my choice to eat meat.

Mike

9.
Elizabeth Brinkley, Legislative Liaison to the American Kennel Club United States says:

Animal Welfare or Animal Rights?

Here are some of the differences:

As animal welfare advocates. . .

· We seek to improve the treatment and well-being of animals.

· We support the humane treatment of animals that ensures comfort and freedom from unnecessary pain and suffering.

· We believe we have the right to "own" animals -- they are our property.

· We believe animal owners should provide loving care for the lifetime of their animals.

As animal rights activists. . .

· They seek to end the use and ownership of animals, including the keeping of pets.

· They believe that any use of an animal is exploitation so, not only must we stop using animals for food and clothing, but pet ownership must be outlawed as well.

· They want to obtain legal rights for animals as they believe that animals and humans are equal.

· They use false and unsubstantiated allegations of animal abuse to raise funds, attract media attention and bring supporters into the movement.

· (The Inhumane Crusade, Daniel T. Oliver – Capital Research Center)

www.humanewatch.com
www.exposeanimalrights.com
www.bewareanimalradicals.com
www.pet-law.com
www.saova.org



10.
ghall United States says:

Vegetarianism is the choice not to eat meat.  It is usually non-judgmental, simply a choice. Veganism is almost by definition, militant and extremely critical of others choices to consume and/or use animal products - Gene

11.
melissa United States says:

Gene - I don't read this blog religiously, but I do try to stay up on it. I really feel like you missed the mark here. Why perpetuate diet-based stereotypes where meat-eater equals redneck and veganism equals militant? Do you, personally, know any people who choose a vegan lifestyle? My friends have never snubbed their noses if I mentioned honey or milk. However, if they come for dinner, I respect their decisions and leave the dairy on the side.

How something as simple as food could become such a hot political issue, I have no clue. What's fascinating is how everyone has their own food beliefs. Believe it or not, it even exists within the meat-eating populations: grass fed or grain fed?

I'm merely defending something important to me.

12.
ghall United States says:

I'm glad you read the blog Melissa.  Your point of view is important to us. I know several vegetarians. I understand my favorite golfer, Phil Mickleson just became one. I'm still a fan but I worry he'll be weak on the back nine. I do know one vegan, and she considers the consumption of animal flesh a moral outrage. We are not friends and she does not come over for dinner. I don't think Mike missed the mark at all. He was only using the words of dedicated vegan leaders who announced their goals for all to hear or read. Of course, his redneck comments were tongue in cheek,but originated by an actvisits. We'll wear the label with pride. As I understand it, vegetarianism is a lifestyle choice. Veganism is a crusade.  Food has become a hot button issue because so many are now dedicated to forcing their food choices on the rest of us. Agricultural people will not take that lying down. It's not a conspiracy theory.  It's a real full blown conspiracy. Your vegan friends are welcome to their broccoli - I like it too.  But I don't want them or anyone condemning my decision to have a ribeye with it.  I hope you "keep keeping up" and post from time to time. - Gene

13.
melissa United States says:

Have you ordered sunny-side up eggs lately? Maybe that salmonella break has something to do with food becoming such an issue. And I'd venture to say it's events such as that which bring concern to all food-eaters, not the decision of meat or broccoli. I hope agriculture people won't take it lying down either...Just something to think about.

14.
mbarnett United States says:

Melissa, foodborne illness caused by pathogens in eggs, meat and vegetables are going to occassionally happen despite the best efforts of farmers, ranchers and food processers to prevent it. It's an unfortunate rare consequence of nourishing our bodies. The fact is, the Center for Disease Control's FoodNet surveillance network says the incidence of many foodborne illnesses continues to decline. I don't worry about the safety of the food as a citizen of this country. It is of great concern when I travel abroad. And more Veggie Power to you for being a Vegan. We respect your right to eat as you wish, as we hope you respect ours. --Mike

15.
ghall United States says:

I never liked sunny side up but I continue to order "over easy." I have not stopped.  I understand it is a risk but its a very small one. Just like my "medium well" burgers. Salmonella organisms are everywhere in the environment. It can be found in plant products, too. One of the last big scares involved spinach. We don't have more Salmonella cases these days. We, in fact, have less.  What we have is a 24/7 news cycle. We are hearing about it more.

16.
RICHARD United States says:

C'mon guys---if there was arsenic in eggs you guys would still defend it....  Let me dumb it down for everybody--this is happening because the hens are sick--they're sick because they are stuffed in tiny cages where they can barely move. Cramming 100,000 birds or more under a single roof in tiny cages creates an immense volume of contaminated airborne fecal dust that can rapidly spread Salmonella infection between birds.

17.
ghall United States says:

Welcome back Richard. I can't remember the last time I advocated arsenic in the food supply. You can't prove that allegation because it's nonsense. Salmonella, everywhere in the environment, can be found in products of animal and plant origin. Caged layers food can be more carefully managed - they don't have the opportunity to eat excrement for example,which a chicken will readily do, and salmonella's origin is fecal. Salmonella can also be spread among animals, IF they have contact with one another. Not usually the case in the cages. It's not airborn, so animals that have contact with one another are more likely to spread it. Just so everyone is clear, I understand that the issue for you is not "free range" eggs. It's no eggs, no meat and nothing of animal origin. I grew up on free range eggs and never got sick. I've been eating the low cost grocery store variety for 30 years. Same result. Everyone should have the choices they want, including reasonable prices. You are just spreading he animal rights talking points.

18.
Texas Agriculture Talks says:

Redneck redux: Eating meat makes you smarter

Redneck redux: Eating meat makes you smarter

19.
Temari Rose Republic of the Philippines says:

Animals are also earthlings. They are no different from us humans. Being the guardians of this planet, it should be our duty to help them live a better life - no matter how lesser they are intellectually or in social standing.

Add comment




  Country flag

biuquote
  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading